The listing says “legal basement apartment” or “income potential,” and the numbers start to look very attractive. Rental income from a second unit can help with mortgage payments and make a detached or semi-detached home in Mississauga more affordable. It can also provide space for grandparents, adult children or extended family, something many households in the city value.
The trouble is that the phrase on the listing and the legal reality are not always the same thing. Some basement apartments were built with permits and inspections. Others were finished years ago without permits, or were permitted as a recreation room and later converted into a rental. Some have tenants with rights that a new owner cannot simply override. Before you sign an offer, it is worth understanding what makes a unit lawful, what can go wrong and how your agreement of purchase and sale can protect you.
Understanding the Terms: Second Units, ARUs and Basement Apartments
“Additional residential unit,” or ARU, is the term now used in Ontario planning law for a self-contained dwelling unit added to a house or lot. A basement apartment is the most common type, but ARUs also include units above garages and garden suites in the backyard.
Provincial legislation passed in recent years requires municipalities to permit, as of right, up to three residential units on many residential lots that are serviced by municipal water and sewer, such as a main house plus a basement unit and a garden suite, subject to applicable zoning and building rules. The City of Mississauga has updated its zoning rules in response, and it has its own requirements on matters such as parking, unit size, entrances and setbacks for garden suites. These rules continue to evolve, so the current by-law and City guidance should be checked for any particular property.
Being permitted by zoning is not the same as being legally built. A unit is generally considered legal when:
- Zoning permits the unit on that lot.
- A building permit was issued for its construction or conversion.
- The work passed the required inspections and the permit was closed.
- The unit meets applicable fire and safety standards.
Any one of those steps can be missing.
Legal, Non-Conforming and Unpermitted Units
A legal unit
A legally created unit has a building permit history you can confirm with the City. Many buyers ask the seller to provide permit numbers, final inspection records and any registration or approval documents. Mississauga has had different programs over the years for recognizing second units, so the paperwork may look different depending on when the unit was created.
An unpermitted unit
Many older basement apartments in neighbourhoods like Cooksville, Malton, Mississauga Valleys and Erindale were finished decades ago, sometimes before current rules existed, and sometimes without any permit at all. An unpermitted unit is not automatically illegal to occupy in every circumstance, but it may not meet the Building Code or Fire Code, and the City can issue orders requiring work or ceasing occupancy.
What “legal non-conforming” means
In zoning, a legal non-conforming use is one that was lawfully established before a by-law changed and is allowed to continue. Sellers sometimes describe an older basement unit this way. That claim needs proof, such as evidence the unit existed and was lawfully used before a particular change. Buyers should be cautious about relying on the label without documents.
Permits and Records Worth Requesting
Before conditions expire, your lawyer can help you request or search for:
- Building permit history for the property, including open, closed and expired permits.
- Any outstanding work orders or notices of violation from the City of Mississauga.
- Fire department inspection records or orders relating to the second unit.
- Electrical Safety Authority permits for wiring done in the basement.
- Zoning information confirming that the lot permits the number of units being sold.
Open permits are common. A homeowner may have obtained a permit for the basement and never called for the final inspection. Unless resolved, an open permit can pass to you with the property. Your agreement can require the seller to close permits before closing or allow for a holdback or price adjustment.
Fire Code and Safety: More Than a Paperwork Issue
Ontario’s Fire Code contains specific requirements for houses containing two dwelling units, and newer units must also meet the Building Code. Without getting into technical detail that a qualified inspector should assess, the issues commonly examined include:
- Fire separations between the units, including ceilings, walls and doors.
- Smoke alarms and carbon monoxide alarms in each unit, with interconnection where required.
- Means of egress, such as a separate exit and windows large enough for escape.
- Ceiling heights, ventilation and electrical safety.
- Heating systems and whether the furnace room is properly separated.
The legal significance is twofold. First, a fire in a non-compliant unit is a life-safety risk for the people living there. Second, the owner of the property can face fire orders, prosecution or civil liability. Hiring a home inspector with second-unit experience, and possibly a fire safety consultant, is a sensible step when the unit’s history is unclear.
Buying With Tenants in Place
This is where many buyers are surprised. If the basement unit, or the whole house, is rented, the tenancy does not end because the property is sold. A buyer takes title subject to existing residential tenancies, and those tenants are protected by the Residential Tenancies Act.
If you want the unit vacant for your own use
Ontario law allows a landlord, in certain situations, to end a tenancy because the buyer requires the unit for their own residential occupation or for an immediate family member or caregiver. In a house with three or fewer residential units, after the agreement of purchase and sale is firm, the seller can serve the tenant with the required notice on the buyer’s behalf. Important points:
- The notice must give the tenant at least 60 days and generally ends the tenancy at the end of a rental period.
- The tenant is generally entitled to compensation, commonly equal to one month’s rent, or another acceptable unit.
- The buyer’s intention must be genuine. Using this process in bad faith can result in serious penalties, and the Landlord and Tenant Board takes these cases seriously.
- If the tenant does not leave voluntarily, an application to the Landlord and Tenant Board is required, and hearings can take time. Your closing date may arrive before the unit is vacant.
Because of this, the agreement of purchase and sale should spell out whether the property is being delivered vacant, which units are tenanted, who is responsible for serving notice and what happens if tenants are still in place on closing.
If you intend to keep the tenants
Ask for copies of the written lease (Ontario’s standard form lease applies to most residential tenancies), rent amounts, the date of the last rent increase, any last month’s rent deposit and confirmation of who pays utilities. The last month’s rent deposit, and the interest the landlord owes on it, is generally credited to the buyer on closing because you take over the obligation to the tenant. Rent for the month of closing is also adjusted on the statement of adjustments.
A tenant acknowledgement, sometimes called an estoppel in commercial deals, confirming rent paid and lease terms can prevent later disputes.
Insurance and Mortgage Financing
Home insurance
Tell your insurer that the home contains a rental unit or a second dwelling. Policies are priced and written differently for owner-occupied homes with rentals. If an insurer is not told, there is a risk that a claim could be denied or reduced. Some insurers ask whether the unit was built with permits, and their answer may depend on yours.
Mortgage lenders
Lenders may allow some portion of rental income from a second unit to help you qualify, but many only do so for units that are legal or that an appraiser accepts. If you are counting on that income to qualify, raise it with your mortgage professional before you make the offer. A lender that later learns the unit is not legal may decline to fund, and that can leave you in breach of a firm agreement.
Protecting Yourself in the Agreement of Purchase and Sale
Ontario’s standard residential purchase agreement generally provides that the seller makes no promise that the buyer’s future intended use is lawful, unless the agreement specifically says otherwise. If the second unit matters to your purchase, the agreement should say so. Clauses your lawyer may suggest include:
- A warranty from the seller that the basement unit is a legal second unit, built with permits and inspected, and that the warranty survives closing.
- A condition allowing the buyer time to review permits and zoning and to be satisfied with the unit’s legal status.
- A home inspection condition that specifically includes the second unit.
- A financing condition that takes account of lender policies on rental income.
- Tenancy clauses stating whether vacant possession is required, who serves notice and the consequences if tenants remain.
- A document delivery clause obliging the seller to provide leases, deposits, rent records and permit documents.
A warranty that survives closing gives you a possible claim against the seller if the representation turns out to be false. It does not prevent the problem, and pursuing a claim takes time and money, which is why verification before closing is still essential.
Three Scenarios Mississauga Buyers Face
A Streetsville semi with a “legal basement.” The seller provides a closed building permit and a past fire inspection. The buyer’s lawyer confirms the records with the City and adds a surviving warranty. This is the straightforward case.
An Erin Mills detached home with a long-standing unit and no paperwork. The buyer can still proceed, but should price in the possible cost of bringing the unit up to code, confirm insurance coverage and avoid relying on rental income to qualify. A conditional offer allowing time to investigate is especially important here.
A Meadowvale home with tenants upstairs and down. The buyer wants to move into the main floor. The agreement must deal with notice to the upper tenants, timing of closing in relation to the notice period and what happens if the tenants do not leave. The basement tenancy may continue, and the buyer becomes their landlord on closing.
What to Weigh Before You Commit
A basement apartment can be a real asset, offering income, flexibility and room for family. It can also be a source of orders, uninsured losses and disputes if its history is not understood. Asking for documents, inspecting carefully and drafting the offer with the second unit in mind turns an uncertain feature into one you can plan around.
Speak With Our Mississauga Residential Real Estate Team
Goldstone Law Professional Corporation helps buyers across Mississauga evaluate homes with basement apartments, garden suites and other additional residential units. Our residential real estate law group can review offers before you sign, look into permit and tenancy issues and manage your closing from start to finish.
Call 905-595-9917, visit goldstonelawpc.com or meet with us at 201-186 Robert Speck Parkway, Mississauga, ON L4Z 3G1, minutes from Square One.
Disclaimer: This article is intended for general informational purposes only and does not constitute legal advice. For advice specific to your situation, please consult a qualified Ontario lawyer.
This article is provided for general information only and does not constitute legal advice. For advice about your specific situation, please contact Goldstone Law PC directly.
